Back to Blog
Workplace Communication5 min read

The Stories We Tell Ourselves Before a Difficult Conversation

20 November 2026Written by Dan Halls
Workplace professional reflecting on assumptions before having a difficult conversation with a colleague.

I once had a yearly appraisal to do with a staff member, and there were some behavioural concerns I needed to raise.

I sat on it for about a month.

Part of what made it tricky was that a lot of the information had come to me from other people. I hadn't seen much of it myself. But if I'm honest, that wasn't really why I waited. I didn't want the discomfort of the conversation.

When we finally sat down, they asked me a fair question: why hadn't this been brought up earlier?

They were right, and I told them so.

I've written about that conversation before. Here, I want to look at what happens before a conversation like that even starts: the stories we tell ourselves.

The story often starts before the conversation does

By the time we're deciding whether to speak up, we've often started explaining things to ourselves. What the other person meant. How they'll react. Whether it's worth it.

Those explanations come quickly, and they can feel a lot like facts.

Three kinds are worth noticing.

Stories about the other person.

Imagine you ask a colleague a question and they respond sharply.

You weren't expecting it. Almost straight away, your mind fills in the gaps.

They've got a problem with me.

They always speak to people like that.

They don't respect what I do.

Stories about how it will go.

They'll get defensive.

It'll turn into an argument.

I'll make things worse.

We haven't had the conversation yet, but we've already played it out, and not well.

Stories about why we're waiting.

I need more information.

Now's not the right time.

It might sort itself out.

Sometimes those reasons are real. Sometimes they sit on top of a simpler one.

In my case, it was discomfort.

Any of these stories might be right. But they might not be, and it's easy to act on them before we've checked.

The feeling comes first

Stories rarely arrive on their own. They often come with a feeling attached.

When someone snaps at you, you might feel embarrassed, annoyed or rattled.

When you know a hard conversation is coming, you might feel your stomach tighten every time you think about it.

That's normal.

Feeling it isn't the problem. The useful part is noticing it before it decides what you do next, because the stronger the feeling, the more convincing the story can seem.

Facts or story?

Professional reflecting on a workplace interaction and considering the difference between facts and assumptions.

One of the tools I use in my Human Skills workshops is Facts or Story.

The fact might be:

I asked a question, and my colleague responded in a sharp tone.

The story might be:

They don't respect me.

The first is what happened. The second is what we've decided it means.

A simple test is to ask what a camera would have recorded. Everything else is interpretation.

That doesn't make the story wrong. Sometimes it's spot on. But it helps to know which parts you saw and which parts you've filled in.

Secondhand information sits somewhere in between.

In my appraisal example, much of what I had came from other people. That's still useful information. But it's someone else's version of events, and it's worth hearing the other person's side before treating it as settled.

Three questions before you speak up

When you notice a story forming, try asking yourself three questions.

1. What actually happened?

Strip it back to what you saw or heard yourself.

Try to separate the behaviour from your interpretation of it.

2. What am I assuming about it?

What story have you started telling yourself, about them, about how it will go or about why you're waiting?

What else could explain the situation?

You don't have to throw out your first interpretation. Just recognise it might not be the whole story.

3. What would be a useful first step?

Do you need to ask a question?

Explain how something affected you?

Clarify an expectation?

Or is this something that needs support from a manager?

The aim isn't to make the conversation comfortable. It's to make sure you're responding to what happened, not just to the story you've built around it.

Start with a question, not a conclusion

Two workplace colleagues listening to each other during a calm, respectful conversation.

If you walk in with the story already decided, the other person can feel judged before they've said a word.

Opening with what you noticed, and leaving room for their side, gives you a chance to test the story.

For example:

  • "I might have misunderstood what happened, but I'd like to clear something up."
  • "When I asked that question earlier, your response caught me off guard. Was something going on?"
  • "I've heard some concerns, and I'd like to hear your side before I draw any conclusions."
  • "Can I check something with you? I want to make sure I've got this right."

The third one can be useful when much of what you know has come from someone else.

Checking your story doesn't mean excusing someone's behaviour.

If something is unsafe or keeps happening, it still needs to be addressed, and sometimes that means a manager or a formal process.

If you'd like more on the first few minutes, I've written about how to start a difficult conversation at work.

The story isn't the whole picture

I don't think difficult conversations suddenly become easy once you've had enough experience.

But we can get better at noticing the stories we tell ourselves, and checking them before they make the decision for us.

If there's a conversation you've been putting off, maybe the first step isn't finding the right words.

Maybe it's asking yourself what actually happened, what you're assuming and what would help you begin.

What's a story you've caught yourself telling before a difficult conversation?

There's another side to this too: how teams and leaders respond when someone does speak up. That's something I'll explore in a future article.

If your team would find it useful to practise this, my Human Skills workshops give people practical tools and the chance to work through these situations together.